CREATE AGRICOLA CARDS   Hello unknown (Sign In) or (Register)

Now Viewing:   Sorted By:   Cards per page:
    [GO BACK to List View]       2 of 120        Jump to:   [Print]
decktypenametextcostvpsprereqauthorComments
2

[View] 		JminorPaper KnifeSelect 3 occupations in your hand and determine one of them at random. You can immediately play that occupation, without paying an occupation cost.1W0uwe[4 Comments]
last post:
2023-05-17 13:27:56
by nwoll


id=8159
Pages:  [1]

 COMMENTSauthor
Paper Knife (minor)
Cost=1W,   Vps=0,   Prereq=none
Select 3 occupations in your hand and determine one of them at random. You can immediately play that occupation, without paying an occupation cost.

[View playtest games] [View all dealt games]		 .uwe
May 12, 2016 3:42am
[quote]
Can it be played when only having 2occs or 1occ in hand? quyuran
Sep 15, 2019 10:06am
[quote]
Quote from: quyuran on Sep 15, 2019 10:06am
Can it be played when only having 2occs or 1occ in hand?

I would assume yes, since there is no prereq.		 nwoll
Sep 16, 2019 12:43am
[quote]
Good question, but in the new edition's compendium located here https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WUl0HlzX6Yx0ume75UmpaIMhoHukx9XufM_LbV1oZ6E/edit#, it says no, one cannot play this if one has less than 3 Occupations.
"Paper Knife (Cost 1W.) A003
Select 3 occupations in your hand. Select one of them randomly, which you can play immediately without paying an occupation cost.
May not be played if you have 2 or fewer occupations in your hand.
If you select an occupation that has an additional cost you cannot pay, that occupation is removed from the game instead of played."		 wallfly
May 6, 2023 3:44pm
[quote]
Quote from: wallfly on May 6, 2023 3:44pm
Good question, but in the new edition's compendium located here https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WUl0HlzX6Yx0ume75UmpaIMhoHukx9XufM_LbV1oZ6E/edit#, it says no, one cannot play this if one has less than 3 Occupations.
"Paper Knife (Cost 1W.) A003
Select 3 occupations in your hand. Select one of them randomly, which you can play immediately without paying an occupation cost.
May not be played if you have 2 or fewer occupations in your hand.
If you select an occupation that has an additional cost you cannot pay, that occupation is removed from the game instead of played."


Hmm, I can't find anything on BGG so I'm curious where Lumin got that ruling. I don't understand why it would be different than the ruling on plows (that say plow 3 but you can plow 2 if you don't have space for 3) and I don't understand why the occ isn't just returned to your hand if you can't pay the cost (which is how other cards work)

I wouldn't follow this ruling unless there is better explanation for it.		 nwoll
May 17, 2023 1:27pm
[quote]
Pages:  [1]
    [GO BACK to List View]       2 of 120        Jump to: