CREATE AGRICOLA CARDS   Hello unknown (Sign In) or (Register)

Now Viewing:   Sorted By:   Cards per page:
    [GO BACK to List View]       50 of 109        Jump to:   [Print]
decktypenametextcostvpsprereqauthorLike It?Comments
50

[View] 		J4occ-3ChairmanEach time another player (EXCLUDING you) uses the "Starting player" action space, both they and you get 1 food (before taking the actions). Each time you use it, you get 1 food (before).0uwe
-2

1Y,3N,2??
[Vote Yes]
[Vote No]		[7 Comments]
last post:
2020-03-28 00:52:36
by wsefranc


id=9878
Pages:  [1]
-2
LIKE IT?
(1 Y, 3 N, 2 ??)
[Vote Yes]
[Vote No]
 COMMENTSauthor
Chairman (occ-3+)
Each time another player (EXCLUDING you) uses the "Starting player" action space, both they and you get 1 food (before taking the actions). Each time you use it, you get 1 food (before).

[View playtest games] [View all dealt games]		 .uwe
Jan 30, 2020 12:32am
[quote]
(Edit: Feb 24, 2020 3:43am)
Is the last sentence indicating you get 2 total food for taking SP?

Otherwise, I don't see why that last sentence is there.		 nwoll
Feb 4, 2020 6:47pm
[quote]
The sentence clarifies that you don't get 2 food. The top of card says 2 food will be distributed - 1 to person taking SP, 1 to you. The bottom sentence clarifies that in the case you take SP, you only get 1 food. chris
Feb 15, 2020 6:00pm
[quote]
The language on this card is confusing... I would suggest:
"Each time another player uses the 'Starting player' action space, both they and you get 1 food (before taking the actions). If you take starting player, you get 1 food."

I think this makes it very clear that you can only ever get 1 food, not 2.		 awlego
Feb 23, 2020 2:19am
[quote]
Quote from: chris on Feb 15, 2020 6:00pm
The sentence clarifies that you don't get 2 food. The top of card says 2 food will be distributed - 1 to person taking SP, 1 to you. The bottom sentence clarifies that in the case you take SP, you only get 1 food.

But the top specifically says "including you". According to your interpretation, the card is not changed by removing the "including you" in the top portion.

But since that "including you" is there, one can only conclude that you get 2 food when you take SP (top sentence) then you must get another food (bottom sentence).

For the card to mean you only get 1 food, it would need to remove the "(including you)" from the top sentence.		 nwoll
Feb 23, 2020 3:07pm
[quote]
UPDATE:

old text: Each time any player (including you) uses the "Starting player" action space, both they and you get 1 food (before taking the actions). If you use it, you get 1 food.

new text: Each time another player (EXCLUDING you) uses the "Starting player" action space, both they and you get 1 food (before taking the actions). Each time you use it, you get 1 food (before).

 chris
Feb 24, 2020 3:42am
[quote]
I think we can remove the first parenthesis now?

I know it was added to alert players that the card has changed.

But now, it just makes players confused as to what other cards that say "another player" without the parenthesis could mean?

I also don't like the other parentheses. The default should be you have to take the action before triggering the card, yet putting this major exception in parenthesis makes it seem like that isn't true. A huge exception to the default should not be in parentheses.		 nwoll
Mar 19, 2020 4:33pm
[quote]
Simpler text:

Whenever another player takes SP, they get one food. Also, whenever any player takes SP, you get one food.		 wsefranc
Mar 28, 2020 12:52am
[quote]
Pages:  [1]
    [GO BACK to List View]       50 of 109        Jump to: