deck | type | name | text | cost | vps | prereq | author | Like It? | Comments | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
27 [View] | J4 | minor | Large Pottery | At any time: 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring: 3/5/6/7 clay to 1/2/3/4 bonus points. (Note: Just need clay in supply like Pottery) | 1S,1C | 3 | Return the Pottery | uwe | +2 3Y,1N,2?? [Vote Yes] [Vote No] | [5 Comments] last post: 2020-11-11 21:06:45 by firnefex |
id=9977 | Pages: [1] | ||
+2
|
COMMENTS | author | |
Large Pottery (minor) Cost=1S,1C, Vps=3, Prereq=Return the Pottery At any time: 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring: 3/5/6/7 clay to 1/2/3/4 bonus points. (Note: Just need clay in supply like Pottery) Large Pottery (minor) Cost=1S,1C, Vps=3, Prereq=Return the Pottery At any time: 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring: 3/5/6/7 clay to 1/2/3/4 bonus points. (Note: Just need clay in supply like Pottery) [View playtest games] [View all dealt games] |
.uwe Feb 1, 2020 5:32pm [quote] (Edit: Feb 15, 2020 5:56pm) |
||
At any time can cause this to be broken. Once per round would be better. At any time can cause this to be broken. Once per round would be better. | sandswoll Feb 1, 2020 8:50pm [quote] |
||
Current text: At any time: 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring: 3/5/6/7 clay to 1/2/3/4 bonus points. Suggested text: At any time you may convert 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring, if you have 3+/5/6/7+ clay in your supply, you received 1/2/3/4 bonus points. (I'm really not sure why Uwe says 3/5/6/7 clay. Does it need to be "exactly" that number? If so, please change the 3+/5/6/7+ to "exactly 3/5/6/7". Thanks.) Current text: At any time: 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring: 3/5/6/7 clay to 1/2/3/4 bonus points. Suggested text: At any time you may convert 1 clay to 2 food. During scoring, if you have 3+/5/6/7+ clay in your supply, you received 1/2/3/4 bonus points. (I'm really not sure why Uwe says 3/5/6/7 clay. Does it need to be "exactly" that number? If so, please change the 3+/5/6/7+ to "exactly 3/5/6/7". Thanks.) |
wallfly Feb 10, 2020 12:17am [quote] |
||
Wait, don't you have to convert the clay to bonus points? Wallfly's text implies you can keep the clay. (I assume the weird language is because the actual card will have icons like the fireplace, cooking hearth, etc. The only actual text on the card will say "At any time" and the rest will be symbols) Wait, don't you have to convert the clay to bonus points? Wallfly's text implies you can keep the clay. (I assume the weird language is because the actual card will have icons like the fireplace, cooking hearth, etc. The only actual text on the card will say "At any time" and the rest will be symbols) |
nwoll Feb 10, 2020 12:52am [quote] (Edit: Feb 10, 2020 12:54am) |
||
Right, it could mean that the clay is converted to bonus points. It's not clear. Quite often, during scoring for the Guilds (Joinery, Pottery & BMW), those resources need to be in one's supply. Really not sure here. Yes, icons & symbols might make it clearer. Right, it could mean that the clay is converted to bonus points. It's not clear. Quite often, during scoring for the Guilds (Joinery, Pottery & BMW), those resources need to be in one's supply. Really not sure here. Yes, icons & symbols might make it clearer. | wallfly Feb 10, 2020 3:17am [quote] |
||
These guild improvements are clear and the rules state it too, also this card says clay [b]to[/b] bonus point, not for each you get. These guild improvements are clear and the rules state it too, also this card says clay to bonus point, not for each you get. | firnefex Nov 11, 2020 9:06pm [quote] |
||
Insert: | |||
Pages: [1] |